No college team has won a title

High school

Related Photos

Mark Rountree

Discussion

December 5, 2005

Anonymous The Enid News and Eagle Mon Dec 05, 2005, 11:52 PM CST

By Mark Rountree

Commentary

Notre Dame is credited with 11 national football titles.

But the Irish actually never have won a national championship, and neither has Oklahoma, Southern California, Miami or Nebraska.

Sure, those schools have shiny trophies in their athletic office showrooms, but those teams didn't win the title. They were awarded one.

Press and coaches polls have been used to determine champions, and since 1998, the Bowl Championship Series poll has told us who is the best.

But championships aren't bonafide unless they are contested on the field in a bracketed playoff system.

The BCS would be more meaningful if it chose the top eight teams and paired them in a single-elimination tournament, allowing for a playoff system to determine the best two teams.

If Oklahoma high schools used a BCS-like format to determine its championship game, no voter in his right mind would have put any teams other than Tulsa Union and Jenks in the Class 6A championship game. But that would have prevented an upstart like Sapulpa beating Jenks in the first round.

Teams should have to win on the field to get in the championship game. But look hard enough, and you can find a computer wizard keen enough to conjure up statistics to prove a four-loss team like Florida State should play in this year's Rose Bowl.

A congressional panel has been seated to study the situation and tell us what we already know -- that a playoff system is the only way to identify a true champion.

The BCS is better than the old system, which was even more arbitrary and subjective, but the current system is like milk that has been in the refrigerator too long.

It's sour, and it leaves a bad taste in your mouth.

Rountree is News -- Eagle sports editor.

Text Only

High school

Freshman gets pin in home debut Brayden Daniels' mohawk hair might symbolize his warrior mentality.
December 7, 2005 1 Photo
Enid lands 4 players on all-district team By Mark Rountree Sports Editor

Four Enid High football players have been named to the 6A-3 All-District...
December 7, 2005
Jaguars sweep Enid By Matt Palmer Staff Writer

MOORE -- The letdown the Enid Plainsmen tried to avoid jumped in front of t...
December 7, 2005
No college team has won a title Notre Dame is credited with 11 national football titles.
December 5, 2005 1 Photo
EHS wrestlers face Maroons at Emerson tonight What's better -- a tightly packed small gym or a not-so-packed big arena?
December 5, 2005
Sports brief EHS swimmers face Bartlesville

Enid's swimmers will concentrate on state qualifying times during a dual at B...
December 5, 2005
Radio/TV Radio Tuesday

Prep Basketball

6:15 p.m. - Enid at Westmoore, KGWA (960 AM)

Pro Basketball

7 p.m. - Hornets...
December 5, 2005
Mustangs begin hoops season By Bruce Campbell Staff Writer

For the fourth time in Brandon Gallagher's tenure at Pioneer, his Mustan...
December 5, 2005
Local scores prep basketballToday's Prep Basketball Schedule

County -- Blackwell at Chisholm, Cimarron at Okeene, Drummon...
December 5, 2005
EHS boys try to avoid a letdown By Matt Palmer Staff Writer

In hopes of preventing any letdowns, the Enid Plainsmen basketball team has...
December 5, 2005
More High school Headlines

High school

Search Results

Related Photos

Discussion

No college team has won a title

Site Map

Contact Us