The Enid News and Eagle, Enid, OK

Opinion

Discussion

September 3, 2007

Merit pay for teachers could be good idea if details fixed

Great concept, but the devil is in the details. That’s the best way to describe merit pay for teachers, a hot-button issue for many of Oklahoma’s Republican legislators.

State GOP leaders have said new teacher raises will not be approved this coming year without at least part of the increases tied to performance. In principle, that makes sense, rewarding the best teachers for their exceptional work. That is the model of business and industry, the better you perform and the better you are at your job, the more you get paid. Top sales people, athletes, architects, waitresses, bankers and hairdressers get paid more than their competent-but-average peers. So, why not teachers?

Merit pay should be a component of teachers’ pay, and a plan should be both approved and funded by the Legislature. The challenge, then, is how to measure a teacher’s performance.

If you judge teachers by standardized test scores, that only encourages teaching the test. Judge by the number of students receiving A and B grades? That leads to grade inflation. Judge by principal and peer evaluations? Possibly, but that’s subjective and driven as much by personality as by competence.

In theory, better teachers should lead to better students, so most plans involve using student test scores. But just as a coach appears more capable if he has unusually athletic and talented players, a teacher will appear more successful with motivated students who are above-average learners, have involved parents, participate in extra-curricular activities, have a stable and supportive home life, and come from families where education is valued.

Compare that with a classroom filled with students who live in poverty, come from single-parent families, have changed schools often, don’t speak English at home, have parents less able to be involved in school or extracurricular activities, have parents or siblings who had bad experiences in school, or have a troubled and distracting home life.

While good teachers can help all students, an inappropriate focus on student test scores in setting a teacher’s compensation could favor teachers at upper-middle-class schools.

All states face the same problems and potential pitfalls in adopting teacher merit pay plans, yet some states have moved ahead with pilot programs or statewide changes. Oklahoma legislators should look at those plans now in place, learn and act.

Merit pay should not be a huge component of total teacher compensation, but it should be a factor. This coming year would be a good time to move merit pay from a 30-second sound byte to at least a trial program giving Oklahoma teachers another reason to grow and excel.

Text Only
Opinion
Featured Ads
AP Video
Sister Says She Reported Brother in Patz Killing Patz Suspect's Sister: I Went to Police in 1980s Diplomatic Expulsions Follow Fresh Syria Report 15 Dead in Northern Italy's 5.8-magnitude Quake Angry Birds Spreading Their Wings Witness Describes Fla. Face-chewing Attack Man Falls Off Crane, Dies After Police Standoff Russia Condemns Ally Syria Over Massacre of 108 Dairy Farm Uses Chiropractor to Help Cows Unexpected Smog in Pristine National Parks Air Canada Plane Makes Emergency Landing New Ticks Spread Across Southeast, Diseases Rise Bring Your Own Tech Programs Charge Up Students Pope's Butler Vows to Help Vatican Investigation Mother of Allegedly Abused Girl Denies Claims Raw Video: 19 Dead in Qatar Shopping Mall Fire Service Dogs Help Wash. Soldiers Battling PTSD Raw Video: Heckler Bursts in on Blair Testimony Japan Farmers Plant, Seek Radiation-free Rice
NDN Video
Couple doesn’t let tropical storm ruin their big day Tori Bares Baby Bump in Monokini Even Fla. Police Shocked by Face-Mauling Attack Letterman on Family Life Post-Scandal Evans: Serena in shock Pregnant Reese Wears LBD Volcano covers Colombian cities in ash Meet the Crew and Good Ship 'Prometheus' Los Angeles Bar Bans Bachelorettes Hamster Plays Dead Beyonce Shows Off 60 Pound Weight Loss at Concert Drunk Women Breaking Into Houses: A New Trend? LeAnn Rimes Rocks Short Shorts Raw Video: Cop Shoots Man Eating Another's Face Gordon Ramsay Carried Off Field Man Dies Getting Lap Dance Kim Kardashian Claims Items Stolen from Her Luggage Bear cools off in Calif. family's pool Ep. 3: Chopped Desserts Air Force dad surprises family at baseball game
Seasonal Content
House Ads